Top is Alan Wake 2, yes. I'm a Remedy shill (Except for Quantum Break and Alan Wake: American Nightmare, those are both awful), so I'm biased, but I'd say AW2 deserved all of those. On the game direction and narrative front AAA quality artfag games (or artfag games in general) that aren't insufferably gay and know how to have fun, and not take themselves 100% seriously are basically nonexistent, and the game pushed graphical fidelity and the New York segments are incredibly good looking artistically.
I'm 99% sure Geoff still gives out the exact same awards, if not more, but they speedrun a lot of shit like accessibility, e-sports, or other throwaway categories in the preshow. AW2 just wasn't nominated for that many.